Peak Sport Products, PC Jeweller, and Honworld Position Sizes 10/30/2016
Peak Sport Products completed its privatization at HKD2.60 per share on Monday October 24, 2016, therefore we no longer have a position in Peak Sport.
We are decreasing our position in PC Jeweller to 2.0%. The company is now valued at 12.9 times EV/EBIT and 3.7 times EV/IC. The company and Titan are clearly the two most operationally efficient competitors within the India jewelry industry, but we must remember, the organized sector is very small portion of the total market and there are no barriers to entry in the jewelry retail industry. As the organized sector increases its share of the market, competitive pressures will be more intense. The lack of barriers to entry means PC Jeweller and other participants can do very little to shield themselves from competitive pressures.
To reach an annualized return of 15%, sales growth of 5% into perpetuity, stable operating margins, and stable capital efficiency must be assumed. Stated another way, PC Jeweller must have pricing power and defend against competitive pressures in an industry with no barriers to entry and over 500,000 participants, which seems high unlikely. Our conservative base case scenario assumes 10% growth over the next five years before fading to 0% growth in the terminal year and no margin deterioration leading to annualized return of 8.6% over the next five years.
We are decreasing the limit on our current sell price of Honworld to HKD4.00 per share. Our position size decrease to 2.0% is a risk measure because during a period of weak growth, when there is minimal investment in inventory the company is unable to generate free cash flow due to an increase in prepayments, which is extremely concerning. Capital allocation to inventory is a big concern as the company has sufficient inventory to last for years and the overinvestment is hurting profitability. The lack of free cash flow, the increase in soft asset account, and it being a Chinese company leads us to be concerned over the factual nature of financial statements. Our initial position size in Honworld, Miko International and Universal Health were far too aggressive. We were blinded to the risks of our aggressive position sizing due to the strong performance at PC Jeweller and Zensar Technologies and more importantly, our assumption that financial statements were accurate representations of the operating performance of theses Chinese small caps. The inability to trust the financial statements of Chinese companies should probably eliminate any future investments, as there never really can be high conviction. For these reasons, the position size in Chinese companies are typically going to be no larger than deep value stocks, if any positions are taken.