Tag Archives: Philippines

Turk Tuborg & GMA Holding Position Sizes 11/6/2017

Turk Tuborg & GMA Holding Position Size 11/6/2017

 

Turk Tuborg’s position decreased 5.1% on May 12, 2017 when there was the first sales with a goal of reaching 2.0%.  The share price has increased and the stock is illiquid. The current position is 3.2%. There will be no further selling.

There is a similar liquidity issue with GMA Holding.  There will be no more buying and the GMA Holding position.  It is a 6.4% position.

Both are high quality companies that can be held for five years regardless of stock market liquidity.

The latest recommendation size of 6.0% was completed over 7 days.

Future recommendations will be in more liquid stocks. The lower limit for 6 month average daily volume will be USD100,000 in the most attractive of situations but more likely it will be above USD250,000 average daily volume.

 

 

 

GMA Holdings Position Size 10/2/17

GMA Holdings Position Size 10/2/17

GMA Holdings position size is increasing to 10.0% with Reperio Capital’s model portfolio as the company is an industry that has strong barriers to entry in the form of economies of scale from content creation costs. Profit growth and free cash flow growth within the industry should mirror GDP growth due to barriers to entry and a mature industry.  Currently, revenues, operating profit, and free cash flow are showing negative growth year on year due to one-off political advertisements last year.

The market currently values the company on a EBIT yield and FCF yield of 18.4%.  Assuming the company grows below expected GDP growth (6.5%) at 5%, the expected return is over 23%.

A. Soriano Corporation Shareholder Structure Correction 2/24/2017

A. Soriano Corporation Shareholder Structure Correction 2/24/2017

There was an error in the shareholder structure table in Anscor initiation.  The total outstanding shares was incorrect.  The corrected table is below.  We also corrected the table in the initial post.

A. Soriano Corporation 2/23/17

A. Soriano Corporation

Bloomberg Ticker:                              ANS:PM

Closing Price (2/23/17):          PHP6.34

6 Month Avg. Daily Vol. (USD mn):    0.017

Market Cap (USD mn):           156

Estimated Annualized Return:            18.0%

February 23, 2017

 

A_Soriano_Corp_Feb_23_2017_Final

 

INVESTMENT THESIS

A. Soriano Corporation (Anscor) is a Filipino investment holding company with investments in many different industries. The company has a healthy balance sheet and consistently generates a return on equity around its discount rate. Despite the healthy balance sheet and the consistency of the company’s ROE, Anscor trades well below its book value currently at 0.56 times book and at 5.46 times cyclically adjusted earnings. There is significant upside to the company’s earnings valuation (110% upside) and asset valuation (77% upside). We are taking a 2.0% starting position as the stock is very illiquid.

 

 

COMPANY DESCRIPTION

 

Anscor was incorporated on February 13, 1930. It is an investment holding company located in the Philippines. Anscor’s largest investments are Phelps Dodge International Philippines, Inc. and Seven Seas Resorts and Leisure, Inc. Other investments include Cirrus Medical Staffing, KSA Realty, Prople Limited, and Enderun College among others.

 

 

Phelps Dodge International Philippines

 

Phelps Dodge International Philippines, Inc. (PDIPI) was incorporated in 1955 and started production in 1957. Its products are primarily copper-based wires and cables including building wires, telecommunication cables, power cables, automotive wires and magnet wires. PDIPI has a technical assistance contract with General Cable Company (GCC), the second largest cable company in the world. GCC was also a shareholder in PDIPI until December 2014 when Anscor acquired GCC’s 60% shareholding for PHP3.0 billion. The Philippine wire and cable industry is comprised of both imported and domestically manufactured products. The four largest manufacturers are Phelps Dodge, American Wire and Cable Co., Inc., Columbia Wire and Cable Corp., and Philflex Cable Corp.

 

Over the past three years, PDIPI’s average return on assets of 16% is well above its discount rate pointing to potential barriers to entry within the industry. Despite the strong returns, the industry is fragmented. There are no supply side barriers to entry as copper cables are a relatively simple product to manufacture and there is no favorable access to raw materials as raw materials are commodities that can be purchased from many suppliers. There are no demand side barriers to entry as purchasing copper cables does not create habit and there are no switching costs, search costs, or network effects.  There may be some economies of scale but with gross margin at only 14%, it seems the cost structure of the business is primarily variable eliminating any real barriers to entry from economies of scale.

 

 

Seven Seas Resorts and Leisure

 

Seven Seas Resorts and Leisure, Inc. (SSRL) was incorporated on August 28, to plan, develop, operate and promote Pamalican Island as a world-class resort. The resort is named Amanpulo and started commercial operations on January 1, 1994. SSRL inventory is 103 rooms with 40 original casitas and 63 rooms in villas. SSRL is a joint venture between Anscor, Palawan Holdings, Inc., and Aboitiz & Co with Anscor owning 62% of the resort.

 

The resort’s services are offered through the worldwide Amanresort marketing group based in Singapore, accredited travel agents, reservation sources/systems, and direct selling. Amanpulo is in competition with all other small 5 star resort companies in other destinations that are generally better known than the Philippines, such as Indonesia, Thailand, and Malaysia.

 

According to reviews on Tripadvisors.com, 90% of Amanpulo’s reviews were excellent, the highest rating. It is rated as the #1 hotel in Palawan Province.

 

Until 2015, SSRL failed to earn a reasonable return on assets. The company also failed to generate any meaningful growth with revenue increasing from PHP517 million in 2011 to PHP645 million in 2016. Similar to PDIPI, there does not seem to be any barriers to entry. There are thousands of luxury resorts around the world illustrating the lack of barriers to entry within the industry. There are no supply side advantages in owning a luxury resort. There are no demand side advantages. If there are economies of scale within the industry, SSRL is a smaller resort, which would be disadvantaged.

 

 

Cirrus Medical Staffing, Inc.

 

Cirrus Medical Staffing (Cirrus) is a US-based nurse and physical therapist staffing business. It places registered nurses on contracts of twelve weeks or longer. In January 2008, Anscor acquired Cirrus. Cirrus has a preferred vendor relationship with the US’s largest home health company. Anscor owns 94% of Cirrus.

 

Similar to SSRL, Cirrus did not generate an acceptable on assets until 2015. Unlike SSRL, Cirrus has been growing its business at a rapid pace. Since 2011, service income growing by 16.7% per annum, gross profit grew by 21.3% per year, and EBITDA grew by 90% per year.

 

The nurse and physical staffing business is very fragmented and there are no supply side advantages. Potentially, there are demand side advantages in the form of switching costs. When using a staffing agency for a large number of employees as long as the staffing agent is doing a good job, the client should continue to use the agent and the agent has a bit of pricing power due to the cost of switching providers. The client can easily offset the staffing agent’s bargaining power by using multiple providers. For small clients, it seems like the potential for a demand side advantage is much smaller as it is easier to find the necessary supply of labor.  Economies of scale do not exist in the industry.

 

 

KSA Realty Corporation

 

Anscor exchanged its old building located at acquired a 11.42% stake in KSA Realty Corporation (KSA) 1990 in exchange for Paseo de Roxas in Makati. KSA develop The Enterprise Center, a two tower, grade A office building located in Makati.

 

In 2015, KSA had an occupancy rate of 96%, generating PHP992 million in revenue, and PHP1,300 million in net income including a PHP517 million revaluation gain. Despite a decrease in the occupancy rate from 2013, KSA was able to increase revenue by 20% over the past two years. KSA’s assets have been revalued twice in the past three years. There are no competitive advantages in the property business.

 

 

Enderun Colleges, Inc.

 

In October 2008, Anscor acquired 20% equity stake in Enderun Colleges, Inc. Enderun was established in 2005 by a group of business leaders, including senior executives from Hyatt Corporation in the U.S., Enderun offers a full range of bachelor’s degree and non-degree courses in hospitality management, culinary arts, and business. Enderun has close to 1,200 full time and certificate students spread almost evenly across the school’s three main degree offerings.

 

Enderun recently launched Enderun Extension, a continuing education unit that is the college’s language training and tutorial business. In 2014, Enderun launched a hotel and management consultancy unit. Several hotels and resorts are under Enderun’s management.

 

Management expects Enderun to deliver double-digit growth in the coming years.

 

Within education, there is a brand advantage at the very elite schools but Enderun does not have that advantages.

 

 

Prople Limited

 

In December 2007, Anscor acquired 20% of Prople for US$800,000. In November 2013 acquired 100% of the non-audit business of US-based Kellogg and Andelson Accountancy Corporation (K&A). Founded in 1939, K&A is a well- established accounting firm that provides tax, general accounting, and consulting services to thousands of small to medium sized companies in California and the Midwest. It operates out of five locations in Los Angeles, Woodland Hills, San Diego, Kansas City and Chennai (India). Following its acquisition of K&A, Prople now employs 373 people serving over 5,500 clients from operations located in six cities worldwide. In 2015, Prople closed K&A’s San Diego office and client attrition in the Midwest. Prior to the acquisition of K&A, Prople’s services included business process outsourcing, knowledge process outsourcing, and content services. K&A tripled the company’s revenue.

 

With the acquisition of K&A, Prople is primarily a tax, accounting, and consulting provider. Professional services, like tax and accounting, have some switching costs as the provider is embedded in the company’s operations becoming an integral part of the team. Despite the switching costs, the industry is fragmented and bargaining power of the provider can be decreased by using multiple suppliers.

 

 

AGP International Holdings Ltd.

 

AGP International (AG&P) is Southeast Asia’s leading modular fabricator of refinery and petrochemical plants, power plants, liquid natural gas facilities, mining processing, offshore platforms, and other infrastructure. AG&P has 110 years of experience serving clients like British Petroleum, Shell and Total.

 

Anscor made its first investment in AG&P in December 2011. In June 2013, Anscor subscribed to 83.9 million series C, voting preferred shares in AG&P. Series B and Series C preferred shares are convertible at the option of the holder, into class A common shares. The subscription increased Anscor’s holdings to 27%.

 

Similar to cable manufacturing there are no barriers to entry within the modular fabrication.

 

Anscor’s businesses do not appear to be competitively advantaged. The lack of barriers to entry makes industry analysis irrelevant.

 

Listed above is the company’s shareholder structure. 50.7% of the shares issued are held by a 100% owned subsidiary. Insiders own another 27.1% of shares issued, affiliates own 3.2% of shares issued, and the public own 19.0% of shares issued.

 

 

VALUATION

 

The lack of barriers to entry within Anscor’s businesses and the management team is deeply entrenched the company’s earnings power is the best method of measuring the company’s value as the earnings generated are likely to continue. Assuming average management and a lack of barriers to entry means the value of the company’s assets should be close to the company’s earnings valuation as excess returns are unlikely and cyclical adjusted earnings should be close to the company’s discount rate.

 

Given the company’s large investments in securities and associates, we use net income as the best measure of the company’s earnings and equity as the best measure of investment capital. Since 2010, Anscor has generated an average net income of PHP1,423 on an average tangible equity of PHP12,106 equating to a roughly 11.8% return on equity.

 

Given the lack of barriers to entry in Anscor’s businesses, growth does not create value and therefore is irrelevant; therefore, assuming a 10% discount rate Anscor should be trading at roughly 1.18 times tangible book value representing a 110% upside.

 

Anscor is trading on a cyclically adjusted PE of 5.46 times meaning in the absence of growth, the company’s expected annualized return in 18.3%.

 

Given the company’s ability to generate a consistent return on equity equal to the company’s discount rate, the reproduction value of the company’s assets should equal the company’s tangible book value. It is difficult to say a collection of assets are impaired if they generate a return equal to the discount rate.

 

Anscor’s fair value is between tangible book (77% upside) and 1.18 times tangible book (110% upside).

 

 

RISKS

 

A company with a dominant shareholder (A. Soriano III) brings potential corporate governance issues. Anscor only material related party transactions are key management remuneration, which averaged 8.8% of net income over the past five years. Key management remuneration is a little high but the absence of any other related party transactions and the cheap valuations means it can be overlooked.

 

Our goal with assessing macro risk is not to forecast the path of macroeconomic indicators but to eliminate risks from a poor macroeconomic position. Anscor’s business is primarily in the Philippines, a country that seems to be in very good financial health. In 2015, the country’s current account was 2.6% of GDP and its structural balance was 0.18% of GDP allowing the country to self-finance all the domestic initiatives as well as decrease the country’s debt load. The country does not have too much credit in the system with domestic credit provided by the financial sector at 59.1% at the end of 2015, which is well below the Emerging Markets average of 97.5% and the High Income countries average of 205%. Gross government debt as a percentage of GDP stood just under 35% with External Debt to GDP at 36%. The one concerning macroeconomic indicator is the level of growth in credit in the Philippines. Over the past five years, the amount of domestic credit provided by the financial sector has increased at a rate 12% per annum. When a country is growing its banking assets at this pace, there is a high probability of an increase in non-performing loans. The country’s banking system has a healthy capital balance with capital to assets at 10.6%.

 

The investment is based on Anscor’s strong financially health. If the company were to leverage its balance sheet, the attractiveness of the investment opportunity would decline.

 

The investment is also based on Anscor’s consistently generating net income around its cost of capital. If earnings in the business were to permanently decline, the investment would become much less attractive.

 

If earnings were to decline making a liquidation value a more appropriate valuation methodology, there is still 30% upside meaning there is significant downside protection.

 

If Anscor were to make expensive acquisitions, it would decrease the returns in the business through the write down of income and equity.

 

Given the nature of Anscor’s businesses, they all lack barriers to entry and therefore are at risk of increased supply depressing profitability.

 

Most of Anscor’s businesses are cyclical in nature and subject to macroeconomic risks.

 

At the end of Q3 2016, 47% of Anscor’s assets were in available for sale securities or fair value through the profit and loss investments making the company exposed to the fluctuations of the Philippines Stock Exchange.

WEEKLY COMMENTARY November 21, 2016 – November 27, 2016

WEEKLY COMMENTARY November 21, 2016 – November 27, 2016

 position-summary-table

 

 

COMPANY NEWS

 

PC Jeweller

 

PC Jeweller reported FQ2 2017 results on November 23, 2016. During the quarter, the company opened five stores including a franchised showroom bringing the total number of showrooms to 68. The company also introduced the Inayat wedding jewelry collection and the Azva festive and wedding season collection, which is selling in 15 independent retailers.

 

Year on year, the company’s revenues grew by 30.2%, gross profit declined by 0.9%, and operating profit declined by 5.3%. Gross margin declined from 16.3% in FQ2 2016 to 12.4% in FQ2 2017. To review the company’s business, the mix between exports and domestic sales and the mix between diamond and gold jewelry sold drive gross margin.

pc-jeweller-business-model

The expected sales mix between domestic sales and export sales is roughly 67 % to 33% with domestic sales having an estimated gross margin of 16-17% while export sales have a gross margin of 6-8%. Gold jewelry sales is expected to represent 70-75% of domestic sales with a gross margin of roughly 10%, while diamond jewelry sales is expected to represent 25-30% of domestic sales with a gross margin of roughly 25-30%.

pc-jeweller-sales-mix-and-gross-margin

The table above illustrates the actual figures on a quarterly basis dating back to the quarter ending December 2012. Since FQ3 2013, domestic sales averaged 72.3% of sales while gold sales averaged 70.5% of domestic sales. Domestic sales averaged a gross margin of 16.4%, export sales averaged a gross margin of 10.6%, and the overall gross margin averaged 14.4%. Using expected figures, gross margins should range from 12.7% to 14.0%. Operating expense averaged 3.8% of sales leading to an expected operating margin range of 8.9% to 10.2%.

 

Regarding demonetization, 32% of sales are cash sales so the company expects short-term impact from demonetization.

 

Overall, the company is operating in an industry without barriers to entry as illustrated by the thousands of competitors, but management has been able to consistent excess profits when peers other than Titan have struggled to generate any excess profits. Given the ability generate excess profits during industry distress and when peers cannot gives us confidence that valuing the company on earnings is appropriate.

 

Under our pessimist case scenario, which assumes a 12.5% discount rate, no growth into perpetuity and profitability fading to the discount rate in year 10, PC Jeweller has 4.3% annualized downside over the next five years. Under our base case scenario, PC Jeweller grows at 10% for a five-year forecast period (store openings) before fading to 0% in the terminal value in year 10. Current excess profits remain over the forecast period before halving in the terminal. Excess profits persist in our base case because of the strength of management and evidence that the company can generate excess profits when competitors cannot. Under the base case, PC Jeweller’s estimated annualized return is 9.1% over the next five years. Under the optimistic case, there is no change to profitability with growth increasing to 15.0% over the forecast period and 2.5% growth in the terminal value leading to an annualized return of 16.0% over the next five years.

 

The table below illustrates our assumptions under each scenario as well as historical averages for each key value driver.

pc-jeweller-scenario-assumptions

 

The company’s management is very strong and continues to generate excess returns in a fragmented industry where competitors struggle to generate excess profits. We will maintain our 4.0% position size.

 

 

PRE-RESEARCH REPORT

 

Executive Summary

 

ABS-CBN is a Filipino media conglomerate with three business segments: TV and Studios, Pay TV Networks, and New Business. The TV and Studios business generates 73.6% of revenue and 92.1% of EBITDA. Economies of scale exist in the form of content creation and distribution creating an advantage for the largest competitors. ABS-CBN is the largest. Unfortunately, the company is operationally inefficient generating an average of roughly 10% return on net operating assets over the past three years. The company’s Pay TV Network business only generates an average return on net operating asset of 2.3% over the past three years despite having a 45% cable market share in the Philippines. New businesses are a disparate group of organizations with no strategic connection pointing to extremely poor capital allocation. The average NOPAT margin of new businesses over the past three years is -253.4%.

 

Given the inability of the company to generate a reasonable return on a competitively advantaged business and the weak capital allocation, the company is unlikely to be considered for investment unless it trade well below book value (<0.5) or at a very cheap earnings multiple (<7 preferably <5). A change in ownership or evidence of the company improving its operational efficiency and/or capital allocation would potentially warrant a change to the view. The company currently trades at over 2 times invested capital and 16.5 times NOPAT well above its fair value based on the returns generated by the business. To reach an acceptable buy price, the company’s share price would need to fall to PHP15.00 per share.

 

 

Company Description

 

ABS-CBN Corporation is the Philippines’ leading media and entertainment organization. Primarily involved in television and radio, the company has expanded owning the leading cinema and music production/distribution companies in the country as well as operating the largest cable TV service provider.

 

ABS-CBN has business interests in merchandising, licensing, mobile and online multimedia services, publishing, video and audio postproduction, overseas telecommunication services, money remittance, cargo forwarding, TV shopping services, food and restaurant services, theme park development and management, and property management.

 

 

History

 

ABS-CBN Corporation traces its roots from Bolinao Electronics Corporation (BEC), an assembler of radio transmitting equipment, established in 1946. In 1952, BEC adopted the business name Alto Broadcasting System (ABS) and began setting up the country’s first television broadcast by 1953. On September 24, 1956, Chronicle Broadcasting Network (CBN), owned by Don Eugenio Lopez Sr. of the Lopez family, was organized primarily for radio broadcasting. In 1957, Don Eugenio Lopez Sr. acquired ABS and on February 1, 1967, the operations of ABS and CBN were integrated and BEC changed its corporate name to ABS-CBN Broadcasting Corporation. On August 16, 2010, the Philippine Securities and Exchange Commission approved the change of the corporate name to ABS-CBN Corporation reflecting the company’s diversified businesses in existing and new industries. ABS-CBN achieved many firsts since it started the television industry in the country in 1953. However, with the imposition of martial law in September 1972, ABS-CBN ceased operations as the government forcibly took control. ABS-CBN resumed commercial operations in 1986 after the People Power or EDSA revolution. Despite being shut for 14 years, ABS-CBN recaptured leadership in the Philippine television and radio industries by 1988. During the 1990s and the early part of the new millennium, the company expanded and ventured into complementary businesses in cable TV, international distribution, mobile services, and magazine publishing among others.

 

 

Shareholder Structure

 

The top 20 shareholders own 98.57% of the business.

abs-cbn-shareholder-structure

 

Lopez Inc. is the largest shareholder at 55.15%. Lopez Inc. is a Filipino business conglomerate owned by the López family of Iloilo. Oscar M. López is the Chairman Emeritus and his brother Manuel M. López is the current Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the López Group. It was first established by Eugenio Lopez, Sr. in 1928. It has holdings in many industries including media, power, energy, real estate, infrastructure, and manufacturing.

 

PCD Nominee Corporation is a wholly owned subsidiary of Philippine Central Depository. Shares are held at PCD Nominee Corporation for other shareholders.

 

 

Current Business

In 2015, ABS-CBN’s generated PHP38,278 million with 73.6% of revenue from the TV and Studio business, 21.1% from Pay TV Networks and 5.2% from new businesses.

abs-cbn-revenue-by-segment

 

In 2015, ABS-CBN generated PHP8,083 million in EBITDA. The TV and Studio business generated 92.1% of EBITDA, Pay TV Networks generated 20.7%, and new businesses generated -12.8%.

abs-cbn-ebitda-by-segment

 

As illustrated above, ABS-CBN has three business segments: TV and Studio, Pay TV Networks, and new businesses.

 

TV and Studio

 

The TV and studio segment is comprised of broadcast, global operations, film and music production, cable channels and publishing. This consists of local and global content creation and distribution through television and radio broadcasting.

 

abs-cbn-tv-and-studio-revenue

 

In 2015, free to air TV accounted for 63.4% of revenue, global operations accounted for 19.2% of revenue, with films and music, narrowcast, and others accounting for the remaining 17.4% of revenue.

 

The Free to air TV business includes content creation and distribution mainly through free TV and radio with Channel 2 and DZMM as its flagship platforms. The content created is predominantly in Filipino and is aimed at the mass Filipino audience. The company’s leading position in the Philippine television broadcasting industry is largely due to the popularity of its entertainment programs, while the news and public affairs programs have developed a reputation for the quality of news coverage that includes national, local and international events.

php-ratings-and-audience-share

 

In 2015, ABS-CBN 41.5% audience share in all of Philippines. There is significant barrier to entry in the form of economies of scale with content creation being a large fixed cost required to acquire an audience. The industry is very concentrated pointing to the existence of a barrier to entry. The top two players ABS-CBN and GMA Network have roughly an 80% market share.

 

The global business pioneered the international content distribution through Direct to Home, cable, Internet Protocol Television, mobile and online through The Filipino Channel. It is available in all territories where there is a significant market of overseas Filipinos such as the Unites States, Middle East, Europe, Australia, Canada and Asia Pacific. Other activities include international film distribution, remittance, retail, sponsorships and events. Similar to free to air, there are economies of scale in the form of content creation with much of the content created for the free to air business can be used in global operations. Distribution is another fixed cost in the global segment intensifying economies of scale. Efficient scale also comes into play, as the global market for Filipino content is not that large therefore the market cannot support many players. GMA Network also produces content for the international market.

 

The films and music business is composed of movie production, film distribution, audio recording and distribution and video and audio postproduction. Films and music needs are generally produced through ABS-CBN Film Productions Inc. (AFPI), more popularly known as Star Cinema. Other movies are co-produced with other local or international producers or are simply distributed by AFPI. Music needs are also managed by AFPI to complement the recording needs of the company’s multi-talented artists and handle music publishing and composing requirements, respectively.

 

The Narrowcast and sports business caters to the needs of specific or targeted audiences or markets not normally addressed by the broadcast business. Included in this line of business are cable programming and channel offerings such as Filipino movie channel, music channel, animé, upscale male sports content and upscale female lifestyle content. It also covers print, sports, and other niched programming via its UHF (Ultra High Frequency) channel. Narrowcast includes the following subsidiaries: Creative Programs, Inc., ABS-CBN Publishing, Inc., and Studio 23, Inc. As part of the company’s goal to elevate boxing as a sport in the country, it entered into a joint venture agreement with ALA Sports Promotions, Inc., a world class boxing organization and promotional company.

 

In the whole TV and Studio segment, economies of scale as content creation or acquiring content is a significant upfront fixed cost. Being the market leader in free to air TV with a 41.5% audience share illustrate the strong competitive position of ABS-CBN.

tv-studio-key-drivers

 

Despite the existence of economies of scale and market share leadership, ABS-CBN’s is only able to generate an average return on net operating assets of 9.9% over the past three years point to operational inefficiency.

 

 

Pay TV Networks

 

ABS-CBN owns 59.4% of Sky Cable Corporation. Sky Cable provides cable television services in Metro Manila and in certain provincial areas in the Philippines. As of December 2015, Sky Cable held a 45% market share in the Philippines. Sky Cable’s main competitor in the pay TV business is Cignal. The company also competes with other small local operators in certain cities it operates in, but no other operator has the same scale and geographic reach as Sky Cable. Given the fixed cost associated with infrastructure needed for cable coverage, size is a key competitive factor. Size also helps with bargaining power.

 

The company also provides broadband internet services through Sky Broadband. PLDT dominates the broadband industry with 65% market share.

pay-tv-network-key-value-drivers 

 

Cable television requires infrastructure, which is an upfront fixed expense. Despite its size advantage, Sky Cable is unable to generate a reasonable return pointing to operational inefficiency.

 

 

New Business

 

ABS-CBN’s new businesses include wireless telecommunications business, digital terrestrial television, theme parks and home shopping.

 

ABS-CBN mobile’s network sharing agreement with Globe Telecom enables the company to deliver content in addition to traditional telecommunication services on mobile devices. Through the network-sharing agreement, Globe provides capacity and coverage on its existing cellular mobile telephony network to ABS-CBN Convergence, Inc. (ABS-C) on a nationwide basis. The parties may also share assets such as servers, towers, and switches.

 

In February 2015, ABS-CBN commercially launched the digital terrestrial television (DTT). The company continues to invest in DTT equipment to improve clarity of signal in certain areas of Mega Manila and Central Luzon with a belief that the transition from analogue to digital will result in an increase in its audience share.

 

ABS-CBN invested in a theme park more popularly known as KidZania Manila. KidZania provides children and their parents a safe, unique, and very realistic educational environment that allows kids between the ages of four to twelve to do what comes naturally to them: role-playing by mimicking traditionally adult activities. As in the real world, children perform “jobs” and are either paid for their work (as a fireman, doctor, police officer, journalist, shopkeeper, etc.) or pay to shop or to be entertained. The indoor theme park is a city built to scale for children, complete with buildings, paved streets, vehicles, a functioning economy, and recognizable destinations in the form of “establishments” sponsored and branded by leading multinational and local brands.

 

Launced in October 2013, A CJ O Shopping Corporation is a joint venture between ABS-CBN and CJ O Shopping Corporation of Korea to provide TV home shopping in the Philippines.

new-business-key-value-drivers

 

ABS-CBN’s new businesses generate significant losses and there seems to be no strategic logic when allocating capital. New businesses are from a variety of industries where the company does not have any particular competitive advantage, which leads to the losses. The poor capital allocation will affect the ability of the company to grow its intrinsic value. Capital allocation is unlikely to change with the current management and ownership.

 

 

Valuation

 

Given the inability of the company to generate a reasonable return in a competitively advantaged business and the weak capital allocation, the company is unlikely to be considered for investment unless it trade well below book value (<0.5) or at a very cheap earnings multiple (<7 preferably <5). A change in ownership or evidence of the company improving its operational efficiency and/or capital allocation would warrant a change to the view. The company currently trades at over 2 times invested capital and 16.5 times NOPAT well above its fair value based on the returns generated by the business.

 

 

INTERESTING LINKS

 

A Dozen Things Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger Learned From See’s Candies (25iq)

A discussion about the lesson from See’s Candies (link)

 

Mental Model: Price Incentives (Greenwood Investors)

An good article by Greenwood Investors discussing discounting and brands (link)

 

Two Powerful Mental Models: Network Effects and Critical Mass (A16Z)

The title speaks for itself, an excellent essay on network effects and critical mass. (link)

 

The Reason We Underperform – Markets Have Evolved Faster Than Humans (Acquirer’s Multiple)

An article discussing potential behavioral reasons for the underperformance of fund management. (link)

 

Anatomy of a Failed Investment (Tom Macpherson- Gurufocus)

A great reminder to never be too confident of one’s views as there is only so much that one can prove to be absolute truth. Understand the counter to your argument and always remember looking for evidence confirming either side. (link)

 

Frozen Accidents: Why the Future Is So Unpredictable (Farnam Street)

The must read blog Farnam Street discusses how complexity and randomness make prediction a difficult if not impossible task. (link) We agree with the difficulty associated with forecasting and attempt to make as few forecasts as possible. Instead, we wait until the key value drivers being priced into by the market are so pessimist that there is little downside.